Headlines

Judge denies request by church shooter to go on outings away from mental health center

Madison County State's Attorney

Edwardsville, IL — Madison County State’s Attorney Tom Haine announced today that a man who fatally shot a Maryville pastor in 2009 during a church service has been denied a request to go on outings away from the mental health center where the killer is being held.

Following a hearing Tuesday, Circuit Judge Kyle Napp denied a request from Terry J. Sedlacek to have expanded privileges at Alton Mental Health Center. Sedlacek sought approval to go on supervised group outings with other patients at AMHC. An AMHC doctor, who supported the expanded privileges, testified that such outings typically consist of four or five patients, accompanied by two staff members, visiting places such as libraries, parks, fishing spots, restaurants or apple orchards.

Assistant State’s Attorney Lauren Maricle argued that Sedlacek should not be granted the expanded privileges because he still has psychotic episodes and exhibits bizarre behavior, such as barking and growling.

“It’s too big of a risk,” Maricle argued. “He committed one of the worst crimes that this county has seen.”

Napp, in her ruling, said she “can’t fathom” Sedlacek participating in a group outing to an apple orchard. “How can that possibly be safe for the community?” she said.

On March 8, 2009, Sedlacek, formerly of Troy, went into a Maryville church and began firing shots. An initial shot clipped a Bible held by the church’s pastor, the Rev. Fred Winters, causing it to spray like confetti. Another shot fatally struck Pastor Winters. Church members managed to subdue Sedlacek after his gun jammed, but two of them suffered stab wounds from Sedlacek.

In 2015, a judge found Sedlacek not guilty by reason of insanity and ordered that Sedlacek be held at a secure mental-health facility operated by the Illinois Department of Human Services.

In court Tuesday, Pastor Winters’ wife, Cindy Winters, gave a statement describing her family’s loss. She said expanded privileges for Sedlacek “would not be justice.” Keith Melton, one of the congregants who was stabbed, also gave a statement opposing expanded privileges.

Sedlacek also asked to have unsupervised time on the grounds of AMHC, which does not have a secure perimeter. That request also was denied by the judge.

Haine commended Maricle, who is Chief of the Violent Crimes Division at the State’s Attorney’s Office.

“Lauren presented a strong argument for maintaining the existing restrictions, and the court agreed,” Haine said. “Protecting the public and respecting the lasting impact on victims and their families are important responsibilities of this office. It’s unfortunate that victims and their families are often re-traumatized by petitions such as this.”

Originally reported by Madison County State's Attorney